(Nicole Russell) In a bit of a surprise decision, the Supreme Court declined to even hear the case the Attorney General of Kentucky and a private, religious school submitted challenging the Kentucky Governor’s COVID-19 restrictions. However, Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch did dissent, stating they would have heard the case.
by Nicole Russell, December 18th, 2020
The premise of the case is this: On Nov. 18, Andy Beshear, the Governor of Kentucky, issued a temporary order closing all schools through the upcoming holiday break, which starts Dec. 18; he allowed that schools may reopen following the break. However, businesses may remain open during this entire time, as well as preschools and colleges. One private school, Danville Christian Academy, and the Attorney General, requested an injunction against Beshear’s order.
In his dissent, Alito explained why the Court refused to hear the case, which seemed to be a matter of unfortunate logistics and timing, and why he still disagreed with that logic.
“While I do not agree with the Court’s denial of the applicants’ request for emergency relief, no one should misinterpret that denial as signifying approval of the Sixth Circuit’s decision. As I understand this Court’s order, it is based primarily on timing.
“At this point, just a few school days remain before the beginning of many schools’ holiday break, and the executive order in question will expire before classes would normally begin next year. The Court is therefore reluctant to grant relief that, at this point, would have little practical effect.”
Gorsuch also dissented and said that despite the fact that the holiday break was imminent, “[T]he EOs remain in force, the dispute over them remains live, and the decision allowing them to stand is flawed.”
As usual, Gorsuch voiced his vehement disagreement with state officials applying their authority too heavily, and using a global health crisis as an excuse. “In their struggle to respond to the current pandemic, executive officials have sometimes treated constitutional rights with suspicion.”
Josh Blackman, a constitutional law professor at the South Texas College of Law in Houston took the Supreme Court to task in a piece at Reason chiding them for punting an important case for the sake of others down the road and petty logistics.
“The Supreme Court did the exact opposite of what I hoped for. First, the Court refused to decide the case on the merits, because the Governor’s order would expire less than 24 hours later (December 18). Second, the Court offered a tantalizing tease about how to review COVID-19 restrictions of religious schools. Justices Alito and Gorsuch dissented. They vigorously disagreed with the Court’s approach to the first question. And Justice Gorsuch seemed to be offering some tea leaves about how the latter question ought to be answered.”
This case and decision comes on the heels of several similar petitions the Supreme Court has received—some of which they’ve heard, some of which they’ve sent back to lower courts—on the topic of religious institutions, schools or houses of worship, which maintain their First Amendment rights have been violated during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Save 10% and get free shipping with a subscription!Fight viruses, remove heavy metals and microplastics, and restore your gut all at once with
Humic and Fulvic Acid from Ascent Nutrition.
MUST HAVE DETOX POWERHOUSE!
About The Author
Nicole Russell
Nicole Russell’s work has appeared in the The Atlantic, The New York Times, National Review, Politico, The Washington Times, The American Spectator, The Federalist and Parents Magazine.
Stillness in the Storm Editor: Why did we post this?
The news is important to all people because it is where we come to know new things about the world, which leads to the development of more life goals that lead to life wisdom. The news also serves as a social connection tool, as we tend to relate to those who know about and believe the things we do. With the power of an open truth-seeking mind in hand, the individual can grow wise and the collective can prosper.
– Justin
Not sure how to make sense of this? Want to learn how to discern like a pro? Read this essential guide to discernment, analysis of claims, and understanding the truth in a world of deception: 4 Key Steps of Discernment – Advanced Truth-Seeking Tools.
Stillness in the Storm Editor’s note: Did you find a spelling error or grammatical mistake? Send an email to [email protected], with the error and suggested correction, along with the headline and url. Do you think this article needs an update? Or do you just have some feedback? Send us an email at [email protected]. Thank you for reading.
Source:
Leave a Reply